The decisions that actually change the number
Updated
Most of an owner’s tax is decided by a few choices, not a clever April deduction. This page lists the recurring ones, gives a short answer to each, and links to the full treatment. Where the answer is “it depends,” it says on what.
Quick answer: The four decisions that move the number most: whether to incorporate (worth it once profit is consistently more than you need to live on — the test), how to pay yourself (salary buys RRSP room, dividends skip CPP — the trade-offs), who keeps the books (bookkeeper, accountant or CPA), and whether to change accountants (what it costs and when it is worth it). None of them has a universal right answer, which is why each has its own page.
On this page
- Decision 1 — incorporate, or stay a sole proprietor
- Decision 2 — how to pay yourself
- Decision 3 — who keeps the books
- Decision 4 — stay, or change accountants
- Decision 5 — employee or contractor
- Decision 6 — what to do with the corporation at the end
- The tools, if you would rather see numbers
- Common questions about these decisions
Decision 1 — incorporate, or stay a sole proprietor
The one owners think about first and seek advice on last. Short version: incorporation pays once the business consistently earns more than you need to live on, because only then does the small-business rate deferral matter. Below that, you pay compliance costs to save nothing. Work through should I incorporate, check timing on when to incorporate, compare structures on incorporating vs staying a sole proprietor in BC, and try the incorporation break-even calculator.
Decision 2 — how to pay yourself
Salary and dividends are close to a wash on total tax by design; they differ in what else they buy. Salary creates RRSP room and CPP entitlement and costs CPP contributions on both sides. Dividends skip CPP but build no RRSP room. The right mix depends on your income, your family, your province and what you want retirement to look like. Start with salary versus dividends, then RRSP versus dividends for the retirement side, bonus versus dividend at year-end, and salary versus management fee if you run more than one company.
Decision 3 — who keeps the books
Three different jobs get called “the accountant.” A bookkeeper records what happened. An accountant prepares and files from those records. A CPA carries a licence, professional liability and the authority to issue engagements a lender will accept. Most small corporations need the first monthly and the third annually. The differences, plainly, and if the books are already behind, what to do about it or catch-up bookkeeping. If a lender has asked for statements, that is a compilation engagement.
Decision 4 — stay, or change accountants
Usual triggers: silence, surprise invoices and filings at the deadline. Switching is less disruptive than expected; the handover is routine and the incoming firm does most of it. See switching accountants and how to switch; how year one works explains the first year, and fees are public on pricing.
Decision 5 — employee or contractor
This one is not really yours to decide: the CRA decides it on the facts, and getting it wrong is expensive because the payroll obligations are assessed retroactively with interest. The factors are control, tools, chance of profit and risk of loss, and integration. The factors the CRA applies, the paperwork difference, and what it means for subcontractors. If the answer is employee, the order to do things in.
Decision 6 — what to do with the corporation at the end
Winding up, selling or stopping are three different tax outcomes, often six figures apart, and this decision has the longest lead time: efficient sales are usually planned years ahead. Closing or selling your corporation covers the routes.
The tools, if you would rather see numbers
Some of these decisions answer themselves once the arithmetic is in front of you. The incorporation break-even calculator and the rest of the free calculators use the published rates, so what they produce is the same figure a preparer would start from. Whether it applies to you depends on your year-end and structure, which is what the question box below is for.
Prepared and reviewed by a CPA at EverStone CPA, serving businesses in BC, Alberta, Ontario and Manitoba. About the firm → · Send an enquiry →