Virtual CPA firm serving BC, AB, ON and MB•Mon–Fri 9:00am–5:30pm info@everstonecpa.com• (604) 832-1743
Home › Tools › Sole Proprietor vs. Corporation
Guide

Sole proprietor or corporation? Incorporation advice from a CPA

Updated

The most common question we hear from Canadian business owners. Here’s the honest, plain-English comparison, and the point where incorporating actually starts to pay off. EverStone CPA walks new BC business owners through this decision every week.

Quick answer: The core of incorporation advice is this: a sole proprietorship is taxed at the owner’s personal rates on all profit, while a corporation is a separate taxpayer that can retain earnings at lower small business rates and defer personal tax. Incorporating usually pays off once profit exceeds what the owner needs to live on. EverStone models both scenarios.

There’s no universal answer — it depends on your profit, your risk, and how much you take out personally. Here’s how the two stack up.

Sole proprietorship compared with a corporation, factor by factor
FactorSole ProprietorCorporation
Tax on profitYour personal marginal rate (up to ~53.5% in BC)~11% small-business rate in BC on the first $500k, then deferred
LiabilityYou’re personally on the hookLimited — the company is separate from you
Setup & costLow — just registerHigher — incorporation + annual T2 & filings
PaperworkOne T1 with a T2125Separate T2, bookkeeping, payroll/dividends
Best whenProfit ≈ what you need to live onProfit exceeds your personal spending

Incorporation advice: the short version

Should you incorporate decision guide: retaining profit in the business favours a corporation for tax deferral and the small business deduction; also weigh liability, hiring and cost
Should you incorporate? A simple decision guide.

If you’re spending everything the business earns, a sole proprietorship keeps life simple. Once you’re consistently leaving profit in, a corporation defers a big chunk of tax and adds liability protection. Try our incorporation savings calculator or send an enquiry for a straight answer.

This is general information, not tax advice. Rates are approximate 2026 BC figures and change with income and circumstances.

Fixed feesClear, fixed pricing. You approve the fee before any work begins. No surprise bills.
One dayWe reply to every enquiry within one business day, usually the same day.
CPA-ledEvery file is handled personally by a CPA, never passed to junior staff.
No obligationSending an enquiry is free, with zero pressure and no obligation.
What clients say

Trusted by Canadian business owners

Rated 5.0 on Google across 26 client reviews.

★★★★★

“…He is very knowledgeable and has saved me tons in taxes by restructuring my group of companies — the best accountant I’ve worked with in the last 10 years, after switching from three different firms.”

Matt Hildebrandt
Verified Google Review
★★★★★

“…We switched to him last year for both our personal and small-business taxes — responsive, knowledgeable and quick.”

Heather Powers
Verified Google Review
★★★★★

“Personal. Professional. Responsive. Plus he saved me a bundle!”

Corrin Skalbeck
Verified Google Review

The forms and the dates

A sole proprietor reports on form T2125 at personal rates. A corporation files a T2 within six months of year-end, pays the BC small business rate on its first $500,000 of active income, and pays the owner by salary (T4) or dividends (T5), which affect CPP and RRSP room differently. Federal incorporation is $200 online; BC Registries charges separately, and a BC annual report applies.

Who this is for in the Fraser Valley

The question arrives at familiar Fraser Valley moments: an Abbotsford or Chilliwack tradesperson out-earning their needs, a Langley or Surrey consultant asked to incorporate, a Mission farm bringing in the next generation. It turns on retained profit, liability and the next three years, and a corporation files every year, earning or not.

Common questions

Sole proprietor vs corporation FAQ

Is it better to be a sole proprietor or incorporate in Canada?+
If the business earns about what you live on, stay a sole proprietor. Once profits comfortably exceed spending, incorporating defers tax at the small-business rate (about 11% in BC) rather than your marginal rate and adds liability protection. Ask about your case →
How much does incorporating save on taxes?+
Mainly tax deferral: profit left in the corporation is taxed at about 11% in BC versus personal rates up to about 53.5%, deferred until you withdraw it. The benefit depends on how much you leave in.
What are the downsides of incorporating?+
More cost and paperwork: a separate T2 corporate return, annual filings, bookkeeping and a payroll or dividend process to pay yourself. For low-profit businesses the added cost can outweigh the tax benefit.
Can I start as a sole proprietor and incorporate later?+
Yes. Many businesses start as sole proprietorships and incorporate as profits grow. Business assets can generally move into the corporation tax-deferred, but mistakes in the mechanics can trigger tax, so have a CPA structure the transfer first.
Does incorporating protect my personal assets?+
Only partly. A corporation is a separate legal person, so business debts generally stay with it. But lenders and landlords usually want a personal guarantee, directors stay liable for unremitted source deductions and GST/HST, and it never shields your own negligence. It is no substitute for insurance.
Do I still file a personal tax return if I incorporate?+
No. The corporation files its own T2, and you still file a T1 for the salary or dividends you take: two returns instead of one, a large part of the higher yearly cost of a corporation.

Moving an existing business into a new corporation is done on form T2057, the section 85 election; its due date is set by whichever party files first.

Ready for a CPA who makes it simple?

CPA-reviewed, fixed fee in writing. Fixed fees in writing before work begins, and no obligation.

★★★★★
“…have been completing my bookkeeping, taxes and financials for the last 2 years and they have been amazing. Thank you!”
R. H. · Google review

Sources

The rates and thresholds behind this page. Rates change — check the source before relying on a figure.

General information, not advice. Have a CPA confirm it for your situation

Starting fees

Every fee is fixed in writing before any work begins.

  • Corporate year-end and T2 returnfixed fee, quoted in writingThis page
  • Monthly bookkeeping, sales tax filing includedfrom $325 a month
  • Payroll, remittances, T4s and ROEsincluded in monthly bookkeeping
  • Books, payroll and the year-end T2 together$500–$700 a month
  • Personal tax return (T1)from $125; self-employed or rental $275–$500
  • Catch-up bookkeepingfrom $2,200 per year of records
  • Controller or CFO supportcontroller from $1,650, CFO from $2,750 a month
  • One-off advice call with a CPA$225 plus applicable tax

Does this apply to your business?

Ask and a CPA answers. Free, with no meeting and no invoice.

Please tell us what the question is.
Please enter an email address we can reply to.

A CPA replies within one business day. No mailing list. Rated 5.0 from 26 Google reviews.

Decided incorporation is coming but not sure when? See the Just getting started for the setup sequence that follows.

Already decided incorporation is coming? When to incorporate deals with the timing, the triggers and the calendar mechanics.

Want a CPA’s answer on whether to incorporate before committing to anything? The 45-minute Advice Call is a flat fee of $225 + GST for one question, credited against your first invoice if you engage us within 60 days.

What it costs. Incorporation advice starts with an enquiry, or a paid Advice Call at $225 plus applicable tax for a one-off question without an engagement. Every published fee →